Ezell v. Chicago

U. S. Circuit Court of Appeal for the Seventh Circuit

Ezell et al., v. City of Chicago
Appeal Case No.: 14-3312
District Court Judge: Honorable Virginia M. Kendall
Case in other court:10-03525
14-03312
14-03322
Cause: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act

Summary/Issues: 2A; Place Restrictions; DP; Challenges the new rules banning gun ranges in the city as violating 1st, 2nd and 14th amendments.

Filing Date Filing Party Document Description
U.S. Circuit Court of Appeal for the Seventh Circuit
5/15/2015 Court Appellant Reply Cross-Appellee brief filed by Appellant City of Chicago in 14-3312, Appellee City of Chicago in 14-3322.. Paper copies due on 05/22/2015 Electronically Transmitted.
5/15/2015  Appellant Reply – Response of Defendant-Appellant-Cross-Appellee
3/26/2015 Court New Briefing Schedule for Reply Briefs
3/25/2015 Court Order Granting Motion to Extend Time to File Reply-Cross-Appellee’s Brief
3/25/2015 Appellant Motion to Extend Time to File Reply-Cross-Appellee’s Brief
3/17/2015 Appellee Corrected Appellees-Cross-Appellants’ Brief
3/16/2015 Court Brief Deficiency Letter
3/16/2015 Court Appellee Cross-Appellant brief filed by Appellees Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated in 14-3312, Appellants Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated in 14-3322. Paper copies due on 03/24/2015 Electronically Transmitted.
3/16/2015 Appellee Appellees-Cross-Appellants’ Brief
3/16/2015 Appellee Separate Appendix of Appellees-Cross-Appellants
1/7/2015 Court Order Granting Motion to Extend Time to File Appellees’ Brief
1/6/2015 Appellee Motion to Extend Time to File Appellees’ Brief
1/5/2015 Court Appellant’s brief on main appeal filed by Appellant City of Chicago.. Paper copies due on 01/13/2015 Electronically Transmitted.
1/2/2015 Appellant Brief and Appendix of Defendant-Appellant
12/16/2014 Court Added Attorney(s) Alan Gura for party(s) Appellant Joseph I. Brown Appellant Action Target, Incorporated Appellant Rhonda Ezell Appellant Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated Appellant William Hespen, in case 14-3322 Attorney(s) Alan Gura for party(s) Appellee William Hespen Appellee Action Target, Incorporated Appellee Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated Appellee Joseph I. Brown Appellee Rhonda Ezell, in case 14-3312 per disclosure statement. Disclosure Statement filed by Attorney Alan Gura for Appellees Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated in 14-3312, Appellants Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated in 14-3322.
11/24/2014 Court Order Granting Motion to Extend Time to File Appellant’s Brief
11/24/2014 Appellant Motion to Extend Time to File Appellant’s Brief
11/17/2014 Court Filed electronic transcript of proceedings held on 08/23/10, 08/24/10, 09/15/10, 09/16/10, 10/01/10, 10/04/10, 09/10/10, 10/26/11, 07/19/12. [12] [6621577] THIS TRANSCRIPT IS FOR INTERNAL COURT USE ONLY. Remote electronic access to the transcript is ONLY available through the District Court’s PACER system.
11/17/2014 Court Original record on appeal filed electronically. Contents of record : 21 vol. of pleadings; 1 vol. of exhibits.
11/5/2014 Appellant Filed Seventh Circuit Transcript Information Sheet by Appellant City of Chicago in 14-3312.
11/5/2014 Appellee Filed Seventh Circuit Transcript Information Sheet by Appellees Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated in 14-3312, Appellants Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated in 14-3322.
10/29/2014 Court Order issued DENYING motion to consolidate appeals and align briefing in light of the court’s order of 10/23/14. [ # 4 ]
10/27/2014 Appellant Appellants Docketing Statement
10/23/2014 Court Order Consolidating Cases
10/22/2014 Court Attorney Rebecca A. Hirsch for City of Chicago in 14-3312 terminated and added Attorney(s) Suzanne M. Loose for party(s) Appellant City of Chicago, in case 14-3312 per appearance form. Appearance form filed by Attorney Suzanne M. Loose for Appellant City of Chicago. [3] [6614691] (L-Yes; E-Yes; R-Yes) [14-3312]–[Edited 10/22/2014 by AD to reflect the termination and addition of counsel.]
10/22/2014 Appellee Motion to Consolidate Appeals and Align Briefing
10/22/2014 Court Filed notice from the District Court that the appeal docketing fee of $505.00 was received.
10/20/2014 Court THIS CAUSE CONSISTS OF MORE THAN 5 PARTIES FOR EITHER SIDE. The following are those parties to this cause as reflected on the District Court docket, yet are not reflected on the Appellate docket/caption for administrative purposes: APPELLEE: Illinois State Rifle Association.
10/20/2014 Court Private civil case docketed. Fee due. Docketing Statement due for Appellant City of Chicago by 10/27/2014. Transcript information sheet due by 11/03/2014. Fee or IFP forms due on 11/03/2014 for Appellant City of Chicago. Record on Appeal from Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division due by 11/12/2014.
10/20/2014 Appellant Notice of Appeal
USDC – Illinois – Northern District
1/25/2015 Court Order Granting Defendant’s Motion to Stay Enforcement of Court’s Ruling Pending Appeal
11/25/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Reply In Support of Its Motion to Stay Enforcement of Court’s Ruling Pending Appeal
11/18/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant’s Motion to Stay Judgment
11/6/2014 Court TRANSMITTED to the USCA for the 7th Circuit the long record on appeal # 291 , # 285 (USCA no. 14-3312 and 14-3322).
11/6/2014 Court USCA RECEIVED on 11/6/14 the Long record regarding notice of cross appeal, # 291 , notice of appeal # 285 .
10/28/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall: Motion to stay # 286 is entered and briefed as follows: Responses due by 11/18/2014. Replies due by 11/25/2014. Ruling will be made by mail. Advised in open court notice
10/22/2014 Court NOTICE of Appeal Due letter sent to counsel of record regarding notice of cross appeal, # 291 .
10/22/2014 Court MAILED a copy of the Fee Payment Sheet for Appeal 14-3312 to PLRA Attorney in the 7th Circuit.
10/22/2014 Court TRANSMITTED to the 7th Circuit the short record on notice of cross appeal, # 291 . Notified counsel.
10/21/2014 Plaintiff Notice of Cross-Appeal
10/20/2014 Defendant Notice of Motion re Defendant’s Motion to Stay Enforcement of Court’s Ruling Pending Appeal
10/20/2014 Court Notice of Appeal Letter Sent to Parties
10/20/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Motion to Stay Enforcement of Court’s Ruling Pending Appeal
10/20/2014 Plaintiff Notice of Appeal
10/20/2014 Court Circuit Rule 3(b) Notice
10/20/2014 Court ACKNOWLEDGMENT of receipt of short record on appeal regarding notice of appeal # 285 ; USCA Case No. 14-3312.
10/20/2014 Court FEE Information Sheet for payment of Notice of Appeal Filing Fee. Receipt #4624128823 for $505.00 on 10/20/14 by City Of Chicago. (tlm)
10/20/2014 Court TRANSMITTED to the 7th Circuit the short record on notice of appeal # 285 . Notified counsel. (gcy, )
10/17/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Agreed MOTION by Plaintiffs Action Target, Inc., Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen, Illinois State Rifle Association, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc. for extension of time to file Motion for Attorney’s Fees and Bill of Costs (Agreed) # 282 is granted. The Court extends the time for filing a request for attorneys fees until 91 days after, and a Bill of Costs until 30 days after, the latter of (a.) the day after the expiration of the deadline for filing a Notice of Appeal in this matter (if no appeal) or(b.) the day after the issuance of the mandate by an appellate Court should there be an appeal. Motion hearing set for 10/23/2014 on this motion is hereby stricken.
10/16/2014 Plaintiff
10/16/2014 Plaintiff
9/29/2014 Court Judgment in a Civil Case
9/29/2014 Court Memorandum Opinion and Order
8/20/2014 Plaintiff Notice of Change of Address
8/11/2014 Defendant Joint Statement Regarding Mooted and Remaining Claims
8/4/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Status hearing held on 8/4/2014. Draft order to follow regarding a joint statement on the mooted claims that are in agreement by 8/11/2014.Mailed notice (tsa,)
7/31/2014 Defendant Joint Statement Regarding Mooted and Remaining Claims
7/25/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Motion to stay 243 is dismissed as moot. The defendant requested a stay until 7/14/2014. As that date has come and passed, the motion is now moot. Status hearing set for 8/4/2014 at 09:00 AM.Mailed notice (tsa,)
7/24/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Certain Claims as Moot
7/7/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Defendant’s motion to dismiss 269certain claims as moot is entered and briefed as follows: Responses due by 7/24/2014. Replies due by 7/31/2014. Ruling will be made by mail. Motion hearing set for 7/10/2014 on this motion is hereby stricken.Mailed notice (tsa,)
7/3/2014 Defendant Notice of Motion
7/3/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Notice of motion set for 7/9/2014 is stricken.Mailed notice (tsa, )
7/2/2014 Defendant Notice of Presentment of Motion to Dismiss Claims as Moot
7/2/2014 Defendant Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss Certain Claims as Moot
6/10/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall: MOTION by Defendant City Of Chicago for leave to file Submission Regarding Recent Legislative Action and to Cite Additional Authority in Support of Its Motion For Summary Judgment 265 is granted. Motion hearing set for 6/11/2014 on this motion is hereby stricken.Mailed notice (tsa,)
6/9/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Motion for leave to file 265 is reset to 6/11/2014 at 09:00 AM. per telephonic request.Telephoned notice (tsa,)
6/2/2014 Defendant Notice of Motion re Defendant’s Submission Regarding Recent Legislative Action and Motion for Leave to Cite Additional Authority in Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment
6/2/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Submission Regarding Recent Legislative Action and Motion for Leave to Cite Additional Authority In Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment
4/5/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1(B)(3)(C) Statement of Additional Facts
4/4/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Reply to Defendant’s Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
4/4/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Reply to Plaintiffs’ Local Rule 56.1 (B)(3)(C) Statement of Additional Facts
4/4/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Reply In Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
3/28/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ L.R. 56.1(b)(3)(C) Statement of Additional Facts
3/21/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1(B)(3) Response to Plaintiffs Statement of Undisputed Material Facts and Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Additional Facts Requiring the Denial of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
3/17/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall: MOTION by Defendant City Of Chicago for extension of time to file reply in support of summary judgment (unopposed) 256 is granted to 4/4/2014. Motion hearing set for 3/20/2014 on this motion is hereby stricken. Mailed notice (tsa,)
3/14/2014 Defendant Notice of Motion re Defendant’s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
3/14/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply In Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
3/14/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Status hearing set for 3/24/2014 is stricken.Mailed notice (tsa,)
3/13/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall: MOTION by Defendant City Of Chicago for leave to file Local Rule 56.1(b)(3)(c) Statement of Additional Facts in Excess of Paragraph Limitation 248 is granted. MOTION by Plaintiffs Action Target, Inc., Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen, Illinois State Rifle Association, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc. for leave to file L.R.56.1(b)(3)C) Statement of Additional Facts in Excess of Paragraph Limitation 252 is granted. Both motions set for hearing on 3/13/2014 are stricken.Mailed notice (tsa, ) 
3/8/2014 Plaintiff NOTICE of Motion by David G. Sigale for presentment of motion for leave to file, 252 before Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 3/13/2014 at 09:00 AM. (Sigale, David)
3/8/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiff’s L.R. 56.1 (b)(3)(C) Motion for Leave to File Additional Facts in Excess of Limit
3/7/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiff’s Response to Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Facts
3/7/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment
3/7/2014 Defendant Notice of Motion re Defendant’s Motion to File Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Additional Facts in Excess of Paragraph Limitation
3/7/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Motion for Leave to File Local Rule 56.1(B)(3)(C) Statement of Additional Facts In Excess of Paragraph Limitation
3/7/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Response in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
1/30/2014 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Motion to stay 243 proceedings is taken under advisement. The briefing schedule on the Motion for summary judgment 230 has been extended as follows: Responses due by 3/7/2014. Replies due by 3/21/2014. Ruling will be made by mail. Advised in open court notice (tsa, ) (Entered: 01/30/2014)
1/29/2014 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant’s Motion to Stay Proceedings
1/24/2014 Defendant Notice of Motion re Defendant’s Motion to Stay Proceedings
1/24/2014 Defendant Defendant’s Motion to Stay Proceedings
12/19/2013 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Motion to amend/correct 239 is granted. MOTION by Defendant City Of Chicago for summary judgment 222 and MOTION by Plaintiffs Illinois State Rifle Association, Rhonda Ezell, Action Target, Inc., William Hespen, Joseph I. Brown, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc. for summary judgment 230 are entered and briefed as follows: Responses due by 2/7/2014. Replies due by 2/21/2014. Ruling will be made by mail.Mailed notice (tsa, ) (Entered: 12/19/2013)
12/9/2013 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall:Motion to amend/correct 239 is entered and continued; Set deadlines/hearing as to motion for summary judgment 222, motion for summary judgment 230, motion to amend/correct 239 are entered and continued to 12/18/2013 at 09:00 AM.Mailed notice (tsa, ) (Entered: 12/09/2013)
12/6/2013 Defendant Notice of Motion for Defendant’s Motion to Correct Summary Judgment
12/6/2013 Defendant Defendant’s Motion to Correct Summary Judgment Record
12/6/2013 Plaintiff Notice of Change of Address for Alan Gura
12/6/2013 Plaintiff Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment
12/6/2013 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ List of L.R. 56 Exhibits
12/6/2013 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ List of L.R.56 Exhibits
12/6/2013 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ List of L.R. 56 Exhibits
12/6/2013 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ List of L.R.56 Exhibits
12/5/2013 Plaintiff Memorandum In Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
12/5/2013 Plaintiff Plaintiff’s L.R. 56 Statement of Undisputed Material Facts
12/5/2013 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ F.R.C.P. 56 Motion for Summary Judgment
12/5/2013 Defendant Notice of Motion re Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment
12/5/2013 Defendant Index of Exhibits to Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Material Facts
12/5/2013 Defendant Index of Exhibits to Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Material Facts
12/5/2013 Defendant Index of Exhibits to Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Material Facts
12/5/2013 Defendant Index of Exhibits to Defendant’s Local Rule 56.1 Statement of Material Facts
12/5/2013 Defendant Defendant’s Rule 56.1(a)(3) Statement of Material Facts
12/5/2013 Defendant Defendant’s Memorandum of Law In Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment
12/5/2013 Defendant Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment
11/20/2013 Court MINUTE entry before the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall: MOTION by Defendant City Of Chicago for leave to file excess pages in support of summary judgment 217 is granted. Page limitation is between 80 – 100 pages. MOTION by Plaintiffs Action Target, Inc., Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen, Illinois State Rifle Association, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc. for extension of time to file Motion for Summary Judgment 219 is granted. Cross motion for summary judgment with supporting memoranda due by 12/5/2013. Responses due by 1/10/2014. Replies due by 1/24/2014. Ruling will be made by mail. Motion hearing set for 11/21/2013 on this motion is hereby stricken.Advised in open court notice(tsa, )
11/15/2013 Plaintiff NOTICE of Motion by David G. Sigale for presentment of motion for extension of time to file 219 before Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 11/21/2013 at 09:00 AM. (Sigale, David)
11/15/2013 Plaintiff MOTION by Plaintiffs Action Target, Inc., Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen, Illinois State Rifle Association, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc. for extension of time to file Motion for Summary Judgment (Sigale, David)
11/14/2013 Defendant NOTICE of Motion by Rebecca Alfert Hirsch for presentment of motion for leave to file excess pages 217 before Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 11/20/2013 at 09:00 AM. (Hirsch, Rebecca)
11/14/2013 Defendant MOTION by Defendant City Of Chicago for leave to file excess pages in support of summary judgment (Hirsch, Rebecca)
11/5/2013 Defendant ATTORNEY Appearance for Defendant City Of Chicago by Mary Eileen Cunniff Wells (Wells, Mary)
10/16/2013 Court Notice of Docket Entry re Scheduling of Motions
10/11/2013 Plaintiff Notice of Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Expert Discovery and to Amend Dispositive Motion Briefing Schedule
10/11/2013 Defendant Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Expert Discovery and to Amend Dispositive Motion Schedule
8/19/2013 Court Notification of Docket Entry Resetting Status Hearing
8/5/2013 Court MINUTE entry before Honorable Virginia M. Kendall: Status hearing set for 8/13/2013 is stricken and reset to 8/20/2013 at 09:00 AM.Mailed notice (tsa,)
7/17/2013 Court Order Granting Defendants Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Expert Discovery
7/11/2013 Defendant Notice of Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Expert Discovery and to Amend Dispositive Motion Briefing Schedule
7/11/2013 Defendant Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Expert Discovery and to Amend Dispositive Motion Schedule
07/06/2011  Court Final Judgment
07/06/211  Court Opinion
05/05/2011 Appellants Appellants Action Target, Incorporated, Joseph I. Brown, Rhonda Ezell, William Hespen and Second Amendment Foundation, Incorporated Citation of Additional Authority, per Circuit Rule 28(e)
05/04/2011 Appellee City of Chicago Citation of Additional Authority
05/04/2011 Appellee Appearance Form for Suzanne M. Loose on behalf of Appellee City of Chicago
04/04/2011 Court Case heard and taken under advisement by panel: Michael S. Kanne, Circuit Judge; Ilana Diamond Rovner, Circuit Judge and Diane S. Sykes, Circuit Judge
04/04/2011 Court Oral Arguments
3/14/2011 Appellant Reply Brief
2/18/2011 Appellee Brief and Appendix of Defendant-Appellee
12/27/2010 Court USCA Received on the Supplemental Record Re Notice of Appeal
12/22/2010 Court Transmitted to the USCA for the 7th Circuit Supplemental Record on Appeal
12/22/2010 Appellee Exhibits and Transcript Designations
12/22/2010 Appellant Exhibits and Transcript Designations
12/22/2010 Defendant Reply in Support of Motion to Stay Proceedings Pending the Outcome of Plaintiffs’ Appeal
12/22/2010 Court Minute Entry
12/22/2010 Court Minute Entry
12/21/2010 Court Transmitted to the USCA for the 7th Circuit Supplement Record on Appeal
12/20/2010 Defendant Notice of Filing Joint Status Report
12/20/2010 Defendant Joint Status Report
12/15/2010 Defendant Notice of Motion for Presentment of Motion to Supplement
12/15/2010 Appellant Agreed Motion to Supplement the Record on Appeal
12/10/2010 Appellant Appellants’ Brief and Required Short Appendix
12/06/2010 Appellant Notice of Filing Response to Motion
12/06/2010 Appellant Response to Motion to Stay Proceedings Pending Appeal
11/23/2010 Court USCA Received the Long Record Re Notice of Appeal
11/23/2010 Court Transmitted to the USCA for the 7th Circuit the Long Record on Appeal
11/15/2010 Court Minute Entry
11/09/2010 Court Minute Entry
11/01/2010 Defendant Notice of Motion for Presentment of Motion to Stay
11/01/2010 Defendant Motion for Stay of Proceedings Pending Appeal or For Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss
10/29/2010 Court Acknowledgement of Receipt of Short Record on Appeal re Notice of Appeal
10/29/2010 Court Transmitted to the 7th Circuit
10/29/2010 Court Notice of Appeal Due Letter Sent to Counsel of Record
10/28/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Appeal
10/28/2010 Defendant Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss
10/13/2010 Court Minute Entry
10/12/2010 Court Memorandum Opinion and Order
10/12/2010 Court Minute Entry
10/08/2010 Defendant Notice of Motion for Presentment of Motion to Dismiss
10/08/2010 Defendant Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs’ Complaint
10/05/2010 National Rifle Association Appearance for Amicus National Rifle Association
10/04/2010 Court Minute Entry
10/01/2010 Court Minute Entry
10/01/2010 National Rifle Association Motion of Jesse Panuccio for Leave to Appear Pro Hac Vice
10/01/2010 National Rifle Association Motion of David Thompson for Leave to Appear Pro Hac Vice
10/01/2010 National Rifle Association Motion for Leave to Appear Pro Hac Vice
10/01/2010 National Rifle Association Motion of the National Rifle Association for Leave to File Instanter a Brief as Amicus Curiae
10/01/2010 National Rifle Association Attorney Appearance for Amicus National Rifle Association by Charles J. Cooper
09/28/2010 Court Minute Entry
09/28/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Filing Response to Motion
09/28/2010 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Answer or Otherwise Plead to Plaintiff’s Complaint
09/27/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Filing Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Allow Additional Discovery
09/27/2010 Plaintiff Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Motion for Leave to Allow Additional Discovery
09/27/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Filing Memorandum in Reply to Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
09/27/2010 Plaintiff Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Reply to Defendant’s Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction
09/27/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Motion for Presentment of Motion in Limine
09/27/2010 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine #1- to Exclude Testimony of Six Witnesses
09/23/2010 Defendant Notice of Emergency Motion
09/23/2010 Defendant Defendant’s Emergency Motion for Extension of Time to Answer or Otherwise Plead to Plaintiffs’ Complaint
09/23/2010 Defendant Amended Notice of Emergency Motion
09/23/2010 Court Minute Entry
09/22/2010 Defendant Notice of Emergency Motion
09/22/2010 Defendant Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
09/22/2010 Defendant Notice of Filing Memorandum in Opposition to MOtion for Preliminary Injunction
09/22/2010 Defendant Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction
09/22/2010 Defendant Notice of Motion for Extension of Time to Answer or Otherwise Plead to Plaintiffs’ Complaint
09/22/2010 Defendant Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Answer of Othewise Plead to Plaintiffs’ Complaint
09/22/2010 Court Minute Entry
09/20/2010 Defendant Notice of Motion for Leave to File Instanter a Brief in Excess of Fifteen Pages
09/20/2010 Defendant Defendant’s Motion for Leave to File Instanter A Brief in Excess of Fifteen Pages
09/16/2010 Court Minute Entry
09/15/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Filing Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Vacate Briefing Schedule
09/15/2010 Court Minute Entry
09/15/2010 Defendant Notice of Filing Memorandum in Opposition to Motion
09/15/2010 Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs Second Motion for Temporary Restraining Order 1.  Exhibit A – C 2.  Exhibit D 3.  Exhibit E – K 4.  Exhibits L – P
09/15/2010 Plaintiff Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Vacate
09/14/2010 Defendant Notice of Motion
09/14/2010 Defendant Motion to Vacate Briefing Schedule and Preliminary Injunction Hearing
09/13/2010 Plaintiff Amended Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
09/13/2010 Plaintiff Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
09/10/2010 Court Minute Entry
09/10/2010 Plaintiff Emergency Notice of Motion to Quash
09/10/2010 Plaintiff Memorandum in Support of Motion to Quash
09/10/2010 Plaintiff Plaintiffs’ Emergency Motion to Quash Deposition Subpoenas Duces Tecum
09/02/2010 Court Minute Entry
08/24/2010 Court Minute Entry
08/23/2010 Court Minute Order
08/23/2010 Defendant Response in Opposition to Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
08/23/2010  Court Minute Entry
08/23/2010 Court Minute Entry
08/23/2010 Plaintiff Notification of Affiliates
08/22/2010 Plaintiff Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
08/17/2010 Court Minute Entry
08/16/2010 Plaintiff Notice of Motion for Preliminary Injunction and Motion for Permanent Injunction
08/16/2010 Plaintiff Corrected Memorandum in Support of Preliminary Injunction
08/16/2010 Plaintiff Memorandum in Support of Preliminary Injunction
08/16/2010 Plaintiff Motion for Preliminary Injunction
08/16/2010 Plaintiff Complaint